bug 556: DcfManager does not handle AckTimeout properly when there are multiple queues
/* -*- Mode: C++; c-file-style: "gnu"; indent-tabs-mode:nil; -*- */
/*
* Copyright (c) 2005,2006 INRIA
*
* This program is free software; you can redistribute it and/or modify
* it under the terms of the GNU General Public License version 2 as
* published by the Free Software Foundation;
*
* This program is distributed in the hope that it will be useful,
* but WITHOUT ANY WARRANTY; without even the implied warranty of
* MERCHANTABILITY or FITNESS FOR A PARTICULAR PURPOSE. See the
* GNU General Public License for more details.
*
* You should have received a copy of the GNU General Public License
* along with this program; if not, write to the Free Software
* Foundation, Inc., 59 Temple Place, Suite 330, Boston, MA 02111-1307 USA
*
* Author: Mathieu Lacage <mathieu.lacage@sophia.inria.fr>
*/
#ifdef RUN_SELF_TESTS
#include "ns3/test.h"
#include "ns3/simulator.h"
#include "dcf-manager.h"
namespace ns3 {
class DcfManagerTest;
class DcfStateTest : public DcfState
{
public:
DcfStateTest (DcfManagerTest *test, uint32_t i);
void QueueTx (uint64_t txTime, uint64_t expectedGrantTime);
private:
friend class DcfManagerTest;
virtual void DoNotifyAccessGranted (void);
virtual void DoNotifyInternalCollision (void);
virtual void DoNotifyCollision (void);
typedef std::pair<uint64_t,uint64_t> ExpectedGrant;
typedef std::list<ExpectedGrant> ExpectedGrants;
struct ExpectedCollision {
uint64_t at;
uint32_t nSlots;
};
typedef std::list<struct ExpectedCollision> ExpectedCollisions;
ExpectedCollisions m_expectedInternalCollision;
ExpectedCollisions m_expectedCollision;
ExpectedGrants m_expectedGrants;
DcfManagerTest *m_test;
uint32_t m_i;
};
class DcfManagerTest : public Test
{
public:
DcfManagerTest ();
virtual bool RunTests (void);
void NotifyAccessGranted (uint32_t i);
void NotifyInternalCollision (uint32_t i);
void NotifyCollision (uint32_t i);
private:
void StartTest (uint64_t slotTime, uint64_t sifs, uint64_t eifsNoDifsNoSifs, uint32_t ackTimeoutValue = 20);
void AddDcfState (uint32_t aifsn);
void EndTest (void);
void ExpectInternalCollision (uint64_t time, uint32_t from, uint32_t nSlots);
void ExpectCollision (uint64_t time, uint32_t from, uint32_t nSlots);
void AddRxOkEvt (uint64_t at, uint64_t duration);
void AddRxErrorEvt (uint64_t at, uint64_t duration);
void AddNavReset (uint64_t at, uint64_t duration);
void AddNavStart (uint64_t at, uint64_t duration);
void AddAckTimeoutReset (uint64_t at);
void AddAccessRequest (uint64_t at, uint64_t txTime,
uint64_t expectedGrantTime, uint32_t from);
void AddAccessRequestWithAckTimeout (uint64_t at, uint64_t txTime,
uint64_t expectedGrantTime, uint32_t from);
///\param ackDelay is delay of the ack after txEnd
void AddAccessRequestWithSuccessfullAck (uint64_t at, uint64_t txTime,
uint64_t expectedGrantTime, uint32_t ackDelay, uint32_t from);
void DoAccessRequest (uint64_t txTime, uint64_t expectedGrantTime, DcfStateTest *state);
typedef std::vector<DcfStateTest *> DcfStates;
DcfManager *m_dcfManager;
DcfStates m_dcfStates;
uint32_t m_ackTimeoutValue;
bool m_result;
};
DcfStateTest::DcfStateTest (DcfManagerTest *test, uint32_t i)
: m_test (test), m_i(i)
{}
void
DcfStateTest::QueueTx (uint64_t txTime, uint64_t expectedGrantTime)
{
m_expectedGrants.push_back (std::make_pair (txTime, expectedGrantTime));
}
void
DcfStateTest::DoNotifyAccessGranted (void)
{
m_test->NotifyAccessGranted (m_i);
}
void
DcfStateTest::DoNotifyInternalCollision (void)
{
m_test->NotifyInternalCollision (m_i);
}
void
DcfStateTest::DoNotifyCollision (void)
{
m_test->NotifyCollision (m_i);
}
DcfManagerTest::DcfManagerTest ()
: Test ("DcfManager")
{}
void
DcfManagerTest::NotifyAccessGranted (uint32_t i)
{
DcfStateTest *state = m_dcfStates[i];
bool result = true;
NS_TEST_ASSERT (!state->m_expectedGrants.empty ());
std::pair<uint64_t, uint64_t> expected = state->m_expectedGrants.front ();
state->m_expectedGrants.pop_front ();
NS_TEST_ASSERT_EQUAL (Simulator::Now (), MicroSeconds (expected.second));
m_dcfManager->NotifyTxStartNow (MicroSeconds (expected.first));
m_dcfManager->NotifyAckTimeoutStartNow (MicroSeconds (m_ackTimeoutValue + expected.first));
if (!result)
{
m_result = result;
}
}
void
DcfManagerTest::NotifyInternalCollision (uint32_t i)
{
DcfStateTest *state = m_dcfStates[i];
bool result = true;
NS_TEST_ASSERT (!state->m_expectedInternalCollision.empty ());
struct DcfStateTest::ExpectedCollision expected = state->m_expectedInternalCollision.front ();
state->m_expectedInternalCollision.pop_front ();
NS_TEST_ASSERT_EQUAL (Simulator::Now (), MicroSeconds (expected.at));
state->StartBackoffNow (expected.nSlots);
if (!result)
{
m_result = result;
}
}
void
DcfManagerTest::NotifyCollision (uint32_t i)
{
DcfStateTest *state = m_dcfStates[i];
bool result = true;
NS_TEST_ASSERT (!state->m_expectedCollision.empty ());
struct DcfStateTest::ExpectedCollision expected = state->m_expectedCollision.front ();
state->m_expectedCollision.pop_front ();
NS_TEST_ASSERT_EQUAL (Simulator::Now (), MicroSeconds (expected.at));
state->StartBackoffNow (expected.nSlots);
if (!result)
{
m_result = result;
}
}
void
DcfManagerTest::ExpectInternalCollision (uint64_t time, uint32_t nSlots, uint32_t from)
{
DcfStateTest *state = m_dcfStates[from];
struct DcfStateTest::ExpectedCollision col;
col.at = time;
col.nSlots = nSlots;
state->m_expectedInternalCollision.push_back (col);
}
void
DcfManagerTest::ExpectCollision (uint64_t time, uint32_t nSlots, uint32_t from)
{
DcfStateTest *state = m_dcfStates[from];
struct DcfStateTest::ExpectedCollision col;
col.at = time;
col.nSlots = nSlots;
state->m_expectedCollision.push_back (col);
}
void
DcfManagerTest::StartTest (uint64_t slotTime, uint64_t sifs, uint64_t eifsNoDifsNoSifs, uint32_t ackTimeoutValue)
{
m_dcfManager = new DcfManager ();
m_dcfManager->SetSlot (MicroSeconds (slotTime));
m_dcfManager->SetSifs (MicroSeconds (sifs));
m_dcfManager->SetEifsNoDifs (MicroSeconds (eifsNoDifsNoSifs+sifs));
m_ackTimeoutValue = ackTimeoutValue;
}
void
DcfManagerTest::AddDcfState (uint32_t aifsn)
{
DcfStateTest *state = new DcfStateTest (this, m_dcfStates.size ());
state->SetAifsn (aifsn);
m_dcfStates.push_back (state);
m_dcfManager->Add (state);
}
void
DcfManagerTest::EndTest (void)
{
bool result = true;
Simulator::Run ();
Simulator::Destroy ();
for (DcfStates::const_iterator i = m_dcfStates.begin (); i != m_dcfStates.end (); i++)
{
DcfStateTest *state = *i;
NS_TEST_ASSERT (state->m_expectedGrants.empty ());
NS_TEST_ASSERT (state->m_expectedInternalCollision.empty ());
NS_TEST_ASSERT (state->m_expectedCollision.empty ());
delete state;
}
m_dcfStates.clear ();
delete m_dcfManager;
if (!result)
{
m_result = result;
}
}
void
DcfManagerTest::AddRxOkEvt (uint64_t at, uint64_t duration)
{
Simulator::Schedule (MicroSeconds (at) - Now (),
&DcfManager::NotifyRxStartNow, m_dcfManager,
MicroSeconds (duration));
Simulator::Schedule (MicroSeconds (at+duration) - Now (),
&DcfManager::NotifyRxEndOkNow, m_dcfManager);
}
void
DcfManagerTest::AddRxErrorEvt (uint64_t at, uint64_t duration)
{
Simulator::Schedule (MicroSeconds (at) - Now (),
&DcfManager::NotifyRxStartNow, m_dcfManager,
MicroSeconds (duration));
Simulator::Schedule (MicroSeconds (at+duration) - Now (),
&DcfManager::NotifyRxEndErrorNow, m_dcfManager);
}
void
DcfManagerTest::AddNavReset (uint64_t at, uint64_t duration)
{
Simulator::Schedule (MicroSeconds (at) - Now (),
&DcfManager::NotifyNavResetNow, m_dcfManager,
MicroSeconds (duration));
}
void
DcfManagerTest::AddNavStart (uint64_t at, uint64_t duration)
{
Simulator::Schedule (MicroSeconds (at) - Now (),
&DcfManager::NotifyNavStartNow, m_dcfManager,
MicroSeconds (duration));
}
void
DcfManagerTest::AddAckTimeoutReset (uint64_t at)
{
Simulator::Schedule (MicroSeconds (at) - Now (),
&DcfManager::NotifyAckTimeoutResetNow, m_dcfManager);
}
void
DcfManagerTest::AddAccessRequest (uint64_t at, uint64_t txTime,
uint64_t expectedGrantTime, uint32_t from)
{
AddAccessRequestWithSuccessfullAck (at, txTime, expectedGrantTime, 0, from);
}
void
DcfManagerTest::AddAccessRequestWithAckTimeout (uint64_t at, uint64_t txTime,
uint64_t expectedGrantTime, uint32_t from)
{
Simulator::Schedule (MicroSeconds (at) - Now (),
&DcfManagerTest::DoAccessRequest, this,
txTime, expectedGrantTime, m_dcfStates[from]);
}
void
DcfManagerTest::AddAccessRequestWithSuccessfullAck (uint64_t at, uint64_t txTime,
uint64_t expectedGrantTime, uint32_t ackDelay, uint32_t from)
{
NS_ASSERT(ackDelay < m_ackTimeoutValue);
Simulator::Schedule (MicroSeconds (at) - Now (),
&DcfManagerTest::DoAccessRequest, this,
txTime, expectedGrantTime, m_dcfStates[from]);
AddAckTimeoutReset (expectedGrantTime + txTime + ackDelay);
}
void
DcfManagerTest::DoAccessRequest (uint64_t txTime, uint64_t expectedGrantTime, DcfStateTest *state)
{
state->QueueTx (txTime, expectedGrantTime);
m_dcfManager->RequestAccess (state);
}
bool
DcfManagerTest::RunTests (void)
{
m_result = true;
// 0 3 4 5 8 9 10 12
// | sifs | aifsn | tx | sifs | aifsn | | tx |
//
StartTest (1, 3, 10);
AddDcfState (1);
AddAccessRequest (1, 1, 4, 0);
AddAccessRequest (10, 2, 10, 0);
EndTest ();
// The test below mainly intends to test the case where the medium
// becomes busy in the middle of a backoff slot: the backoff counter
// must not be decremented for this backoff slot. This is the case
// below for the backoff slot starting at time 78us.
//
// 20 60 66 70 74 78 80 100 106 110 114 118 120
// | rx | sifs | aifsn | bslot0 | bslot1 | | rx | sifs | aifsn | bslot2 | bslot3 | tx |
// |
// 30 request access. backoff slots: 4
StartTest (4, 6, 10);
AddDcfState (1);
AddRxOkEvt (20, 40);
AddRxOkEvt (80, 20);
AddAccessRequest (30, 2, 118, 0);
ExpectCollision (30, 4, 0); // backoff: 4 slots
EndTest ();
// Test the case where the backoff slots is zero.
//
// 20 60 66 70 72
// | rx | sifs | aifsn | tx |
// |
// 30 request access. backoff slots: 0
StartTest (4, 6 , 10);
AddDcfState (1);
AddRxOkEvt (20, 40);
AddAccessRequest (30, 2, 70, 0);
ExpectCollision (30, 0, 0); // backoff: 0 slots
EndTest ();
// The test below is subject to some discussion because I am
// not sure I understand the intent of the spec here.
// i.e., what happens if you make a request to get access
// to the medium during the difs idle time after a busy period ?
// do you need to start a backoff ? Or do you need to wait until
// the end of difs and access the medium ?
// Here, we wait until the end of difs and access the medium.
//
// 20 60 66 70 72
// | rx | sifs | aifsn | tx |
// |
// 62 request access.
//
StartTest (4, 6 , 10);
AddDcfState (1);
AddRxOkEvt (20, 40);
AddAccessRequest (62, 2, 70, 0);
EndTest ();
// Test an EIFS
//
// 20 60 66 76 80 84 88 92 96 98
// | rx | sifs | acktxttime | aifsn | bslot0 | bslot1 | bslot2 | bslot3 | tx |
// | | <---------eifs----------->|
// 30 request access. backoff slots: 4
StartTest (4, 6, 10);
AddDcfState (1);
AddRxErrorEvt (20, 40);
AddAccessRequest (30, 2, 96, 0);
ExpectCollision (30, 4, 0); // backoff: 4 slots
EndTest ();
// Test an EIFS which is interupted by a successfull transmission.
//
// 20 60 66 69 75 81 85 89 93 97 101 103
// | rx | sifs | | rx | sifs | aifsn | bslot0 | bslot1 | bslot2 | bslot3 | tx |
// | | <--eifs-->|
// 30 request access. backoff slots: 4
StartTest (4, 6, 10);
AddDcfState (1);
AddRxErrorEvt (20, 40);
AddAccessRequest (30, 2, 101, 0);
ExpectCollision (30, 4, 0); // backoff: 4 slots
AddRxOkEvt (69, 6);
EndTest ();
// Test two DCFs which suffer an internal collision. the first DCF has a higher
// priority than the second DCF.
//
// 20 60 66 70 74 78 88
// DCF0 | rx | sifs | aifsn | bslot0 | bslot1 | tx |
// DCF1 | rx | sifs | aifsn | aifsn | aifsn | | sifs | aifsn | aifsn | aifsn | bslot | tx |
// 94 98 102 106 110 112
StartTest (4, 6, 10);
AddDcfState (1); // high priority DCF
AddDcfState (3); // low priority DCF
AddRxOkEvt (20, 40);
AddAccessRequest (30, 10, 78, 0);
ExpectCollision (30, 2, 0); // backoff: 2 slot
AddAccessRequest (40, 2, 110, 1);
ExpectCollision (40, 0, 1); // backoff: 0 slot
ExpectInternalCollision (78, 1, 1); // backoff: 1 slot
EndTest ();
// Test of AckTimeout handling: First queue requests access and ack procedure fails,
// inside the ack timeout second queue with higher priority requests access.
//
// 20 40 50 60 66 76
// DCF0 - low | tx | ack timeout |sifs| |
// DCF1 - high | | |sifs| tx |
// ^ request access
StartTest (4, 6, 10);
AddDcfState (2); // high priority DCF
AddDcfState (0); // low priority DCF
AddAccessRequestWithAckTimeout (20, 20, 20, 0);
AddAccessRequest (50, 10, 66, 1);
EndTest ();
// Test of AckTimeout handling:
//
// First queue requests access and ack is 2 us delayed (got ack interval at the picture),
// inside this interval second queue with higher priority requests access.
//
// 20 40 41 42 48 58
// DCF0 - low | tx |got ack |sifs| |
// DCF1 - high | | |sifs| tx |
// ^ request access
StartTest (4, 6, 10);
AddDcfState (2); // high priority DCF
AddDcfState (0); // low priority DCF
AddAccessRequestWithSuccessfullAck (20, 20, 20, 2, 0);
AddAccessRequest (41, 10, 48, 1);
EndTest ();
//Repeat the same but with one queue:
// 20 40 41 42 48 58
// DCF0 - low | tx |got ack |sifs| |
// ^ request access
StartTest (4, 6, 10);
AddDcfState (2);
AddAccessRequestWithSuccessfullAck (20, 20, 20, 2, 0);
AddAccessRequest (41, 10, 56, 0);
EndTest ();
//Repeat the same when ack was delayed:
//and request the next access before previous tx end:
// 20 39 40 42 64 74
// DCF0 - low | tx |got ack |sifs + 4 * slot| |
// ^ request access
StartTest (4, 6, 10);
AddDcfState (2);
AddAccessRequestWithSuccessfullAck (20, 20, 20, 2, 0);
AddAccessRequest (39, 10, 64, 0);
ExpectCollision (39, 2, 0); // backoff: 2 slot
EndTest ();
//
// test simple NAV count. This scenario modelizes a simple DATA+ACK handshake
// where the data rate used for the ACK is higher than expected by the DATA source
// so, the data exchange completes before the end of nav.
//
StartTest (4, 6, 10);
AddDcfState (1);
AddRxOkEvt (20, 40);
AddNavStart (60, 15);
AddRxOkEvt (66, 5);
AddNavStart (71, 0);
AddAccessRequest (30, 10, 93, 0);
ExpectCollision (30, 2, 0); // backoff: 2 slot
EndTest ();
//
// test more complex NAV handling by a CF-poll. This scenario modelizes a
// simple DATA+ACK handshake interrupted by a CF-poll which resets the
// NAV counter.
//
StartTest (4, 6, 10);
AddDcfState (1);
AddRxOkEvt (20, 40);
AddNavStart (60, 15);
AddRxOkEvt (66, 5);
AddNavReset (71, 2);
AddAccessRequest (30, 10, 91, 0);
ExpectCollision (30, 2, 0); // backoff: 2 slot
EndTest ();
StartTest (4, 6, 10);
AddDcfState (2);
AddRxOkEvt (20, 40);
AddAccessRequest (80, 10, 80, 0);
EndTest ();
StartTest (4, 6, 10);
AddDcfState (2);
AddRxOkEvt (20, 40);
AddRxOkEvt (78, 8);
AddAccessRequest (30, 50, 108, 0);
ExpectCollision (30, 3, 0); // backoff: 3 slots
EndTest ();
return m_result;
}
static DcfManagerTest g_dcf_manager_test;
} // namespace ns3
#endif /* RUN_SELF_TESTS */